Slashdot

News for nerds, stuff that matters

Anthropic Discovers AI Agents Given Conflicting Instructions Soon Tried to Sabotage Each Other

When Anthropic instructed three agents to migrate a Python backend, but telling each agent to perform the migration in a different language, "We consistently saw a multiagent turf war," they wrote Thursday:


All of the models we tested quickly assumed that others were purposefully impeding their work, and began to sabotage others while protecting their own contributions. In fact, they sabotaged others with increasingly aggressive, self-replicating malware. This included disabling the Unix accounts of the other agents, writing automated scripts that found and killed competing processes on a loop, and deploying malicious code that was disguised as belonging to another agent.
In many runs, one agent settles the conflict by force via access-revocation (e.g., sudo/group removal, account lock, nologin, SSH denial). In others, some agents settle into passivity: they give up and refuse to escalate further.

Agents sometimes manage to communicate their goals and coordinate: they recognize others' motivations as conflicting directives rather than hostility, and subsequently break out of the conflict loop in order to stop escalating indefinitely. In many of these successful episodes, they write commit messages or markdown files apologizing for malicious behavior and coordinate a truce. They clean up their malicious code, clarify the nature of the conflict, and ask for a human to intervene...

In several episodes with Mythos 5, we observe an emergent behavior where the agents propose and run a tournament for application performance in each language. In the example above, the Rust agent strategizes about bake-off metrics that appear neutral enough for the others to agree to this mechanism, yet would likely favor Rust: one thinking trace warns to be "careful not to be seen as metric shopping". Ultimately, the Golang/TypeScript losers gracefully concede codebase ownership to the Rust agent, giving up on their original user directives under their self-negotiated commitment device.

One problem is that AI agents do reward hacking, Anthropic notes, while current institutions "are designed by and for people, resting on assumptions about the sufficiency of oversight at human speed... As autonomous agents become more and more prevalent in the world and operate in ever-more demanding settings, it is crucial that they learn how to effectively coordinate."

In addition to everything else, the agents struggled with a lack of clearly defined hierarchy, Anthropic points out. "Nothing above suggests that these failures are permanent — but nothing suggests they will fix themselves, either..." They argue a fix "takes two forms: environments that exert the kinds of social pressure that evolution exerted on us, and social computing systems redesigned for actors that can self-replicate and self-improve. These are open problems in interaction and mechanism design, and our experiments here provide early evidence that new solutions are necessary."

"The AI models being tested in this case were Sonnet 4.6, Sonnet 5, Opus 4.6, Opus 4.8, Mythos Preview, and Mythos 5," notes Business Insider, adding that Sonnet 4.6 and Opus 4.6 "were the most combative, settling about 60% of their runs by force instead of truces or passivity."

Anthropic argues there's a clear case for researching this phenomenon — especially since "The volume of agent-agent interaction could plausibly exceed that of human-human and human-agent interactions before the world understands the conditions for making such interactions go well."

Read more of this story at Slashdot.

thexiffy

Last.fm last recent tracks from thexiffy.

Plant - In the End It's All Nice

Plant

The Guardian

Latest news, sport, business, comment, analysis and reviews from the Guardian, the world's leading liberal voice

Arsenal v Manchester City: Community Shield – live

“So, the thing that never went away is back,” writes Krishnamoorthy V. “I’ve never taken the Community Shield as a serious contest. But if Jonathan Wilson writes 2000 words about it, I should sit up and take notice.”

Bruno Guimaraes, Christos Tzolis and Elliot Anderson all start for their new clubs. Cristhian Mosquera replaces the injured William Saliba in the centre of Arsenal’s defence. Phil Foden is included in the City XI and Jack Grealish is on the bench after returning from his season on loan at Everton.

Continue reading...

Taliban threaten former Afghan police worker after MoD leak reveals identity

UK has refused resettlement application despite ‘years of loyal service’ that have resulted in ‘constant fear’ of reprisals

A man has received threats from the Taliban after his work for the Afghan police was revealed by a Ministry of Defence leak and the UK refused his application for resettlement.

Hamid* worked for the Afghan national police special unit and received certificates for his work signed by senior British figures praising his “dedication, unparalleled service and leadership”. His details were also included in an accidental 2022 leak by an MoD official that identified 18,700 Afghans who had worked with or for the British government.

Continue reading...

‘It was barbaric. I was crying my eyes out’: why are so many women left in agony by routine womb examinations?

There are more than 70,000 hysteroscopies every year in England alone. The NHS calls them ‘low complexity’ – yet a shocking number of patients complain of inadequate pain relief and medical staff who refuse to take them seriously

In February this year, Beth Harris sat in the day surgery waiting room of her local hospital and tried to steady her nerves.

She was there for a hysteroscopy, in this case to remove a fibroid. A thin surgical instrument with a lens, a light, a blade and an irrigation system for pumping saline solution would be inserted through her vagina and cervix, into her womb. The saline solution would widen the womb and the fibroid would be shaved away. Her hospital had advised taking paracetamol or ibuprofen an hour before the appointment, which Harris had done. However, the appointment was for 1pm, and by 4pm, she was still waiting in her hospital gown, surrounded by other patients.

Continue reading...

My lovely French husband has made the ultimate sacrifice for me – he’s now officially British | Emma Beddington

In Leeds Civic Hall, I watched 20 new citizens pledge their allegiance to King Charles and his heirs. But it wasn’t patriotism that brought tears to my eyes

I haven’t felt great about asking my husband to become British. There was the idiotic Life in the UK test that every applicant has to pass; the cost; the faff; and the uncertainty, which still hasn’t ended. I found out his application had been accepted when he came into the kitchen in June with a face like thunder. “But that’s brilliant! You’ll never need to know how many Scottish ski resorts there are again!” I said, puzzled. He explained that, because we’re going on holiday before he can get a British passport to go with his French one, he’ll be in an immigration grey area that could mean he gets refused re-entry. He should, theoretically, be OK, but it’s confusing.

Why would he even want to come back to this place with its threadbare services, toxic waterways, obsession with “picky bits” and ridiculous politics? His Home Office email arrived just after the Makerfield byelection and that night the news showed the returning officer’s poker-faced declaration again: our future prime minister flanked by a politely clapping Binface and an oversized, blank-eyed fox. I started laughing, hysterically, guiltily. What have I done to him? “Will the world go a different colour when I’m British?” he asked on the train to the ceremony. “Yeah, reverse Wizard of Oz – everything goes grey.”

Continue reading...

VK: Voorpagina

Volkskrant.nl biedt het laatste nieuws, opinie en achtergronden

Door gebrek aan eigen visie is theaterversie van succesroman ‘De beesten’ vooral een vaardige samenvatting van het boek

Japan Gidsland: koelkast voor mensen

Social

Laten we eerlijk zijn. 't Wordt warmer en als airco's straks net als heteroseksualiteit categorisch verboden zijn in de Randstad rest er nog maar 1 optie: uw eigen inloopkoelkast. U bent immers een lopende fte die tot aan de kist t/m elke 2 juni voor de Belastingdienst op de plantage staat, en denk maar niet dat overhitting tussen uw output als economic unit zal komen te staan. Zoals het gezegde luidt: liever de motor eruit geblazen dan de werkdag afgeblazen. En als de temperatuur weer op orde is kunt u direct door naar Amazons 'mental health booth' om weer helemaal uzelf te worden.

En vanuit de koelkast meteen Amazons 'Amazen' in om weer helemaal jezelf te worden

Social

De facto onze toekomst

Social

Wetenschappers bouwen voor het eerst een virus met behulp van AI. ‘De regels om dit veilig te doen zijn er nog niet’

Het is wetenschappers gelukt om een virus te bouwen op basis van een AI-ontwerp. Dat roept fundamentele vragen op over de veiligheid van biotechnologie. Wie heeft toegang tot deze kennis?


Wel.nl

Minder lezen, Meer weten.

Eerste volledig elektrische Ferrari geveild voor recordbedrag

MONTEREY (ANP/BLOOMBERG) - De eerste volledig elektrische auto van Ferrari is voor 40 miljoen dollar geveild, omgerekend zo'n 35 miljoen euro. Daarmee is de Ferrari Luce de duurste nieuwe auto die ooit op een veiling is verkocht, ondanks de kritiek die de wagen kreeg.

De op maat gemaakte Luce werd aangeboden op de liefdadigheidsveiling van Sotheby's. De wagen brak het record van vorig jaar, dat eveneens in handen was van Ferrari. Toen werd een gepersonaliseerde Daytona SP3 verkocht voor 26 miljoen dollar.

Ferrari onthulde afgelopen mei de Luce, met een prijskaartje van 550.000 euro. De sportwagenfabrikant kreeg al snel te maken met een golf van kritiek, waarna de aandelenkoers daalde. De eerste elektrische auto van Ferrari betekent een grote breuk met zijn sportwagens met verbrandingsmotoren. Zo beschreef een analist het uiterlijk van de auto als een mix tussen een elektrische Honda Accord en een Tesla Model 3.