404 Media

404 Media is an independent media company founded by technology journalists Jason Koebler, Emanuel Maiberg, Samantha Cole, and Joseph Cox.

'Defense by ChatGPT'

'Defense by ChatGPT'

We've written a lot about how AI generated writing has collided with – and created chaos for – the legal system in the last few years, from lawyers using it to do their research and filings for them to judges getting extremely fed up with dealing with these attorneys. In some cases, judges have sanctioned offending attorneys thousands of dollars for using AI to do their jobs, and lawyers give endless excuses when they're busted, with some calling it a “cautionary tale." Today's story is about how the DOJ is getting involved: by trying to catch attorneys doing "defense by ChatGPT."

The Department of Justice Is Using AI Detector Pangram Against Defense Attorneys

Lawyers for the Department of Justice are using the AI writing detection service Pangram to argue that opposing attorneys are using AI to write legal arguments, and in one case told the court that opposing counsel was doing “defense by ChatGPT,” and writing “AI slop” filings, according to court filings reviewed by 404 Media. 

Over the last few years, we have documented many attorneys getting caught by judges using AI after citing hallucinated cases that do not exist. The filings in this court case over the past month show attorneys, including those working for the government, are trying to catch each other using AI, then are citing their opponents’ AI use in their arguments to the court.

“This case has turned into defense by ChatGPT,” government attorneys wrote in the case, which centers around a high-profile voter fraud case. “Motions practice in this case is the equivalent of writing responses to documents generated by a robot that is attempting to practice law. It cannot be that the local rules envisioned that it was acceptable for defense to use what the kids would call ‘AI slop’ to create multiple frivolous motions that waste judicial resources and fail to serve the cause of justice.”

Read the rest of this story here.

MORE FROM 404

404 contributor Matthew Gault took the bullet for us all: “Three hours and 15 minutes into the four hour long documentary Musk, a video game avatar of the titular billionaire picks up a chainsaw off the Resolute Desk in the Oval Office. Shot like a first-person shooter, the audience watches as Musk wields the chainsaw to destroy various government buildings. Walking through a farm, Musk aims the chainsaw at grain silos labeled ‘USDA’ and lightning arcs from its spinning blades. The silo explodes and cows moo in distress. In my experience, the purpose of a video game chainsaw is to viscerally rend through objects. I have never seen one shoot lightning. It’s a small detail that speaks to my overall problem with Alex Gibney’s Musk: it’s cringe.”


The Department of Justice Is Using AI Detector Pangram Against Defense Attorneys

The Department of Justice Is Using AI Detector Pangram Against Defense Attorneys

Lawyers for the Department of Justice are using the AI writing detection service Pangram to argue that opposing attorneys are using AI to write legal arguments, and in one case told the court that opposing counsel was doing “defense by ChatGPT,” and writing “AI slop” filings, according to court filings reviewed by 404 Media. 

Over the last few years, we have documented many attorneys getting caught by judges using AI after citing hallucinated cases that do not exist. The filings in this court case over the past month show attorneys, including those working for the government, are trying to catch each other using AI, then are citing their opponents’ AI use in their arguments to the court.

“This case has turned into defense by ChatGPT,” government attorneys wrote in the case, which centers around a high-profile voter fraud case. “Motions practice in this case is the equivalent of writing responses to documents generated by a robot that is attempting to practice law. It cannot be that the local rules envisioned that it was acceptable for defense to use what the kids would call ‘AI slop’ to create multiple frivolous motions that waste judicial resources and fail to serve the cause of justice.”

The defendant is Khalwinder Bhengura, an Indian man who entered the United States on an immigrant visa in 2022 and illegally — and apparently accidentally, according to his lawyers — registered to vote in Texas in 2024 after falsely stating that he was an American citizen on his application for a driver’s license. Bhengura was arrested in September on charges of lying about his citizenship status, illegally registering to vote, and illegally voting in the 2024 election, and was found guilty in October on two of the three counts. His family and lawyers have argued that the whole thing is a misunderstanding, and that Bhengura, who is 70 years old and does not speak English well, did not know he was committing a crime and did not understand what he was doing. 

Bhengura has been in prison for months and is set to be deported. He is now not only being held up as an example by the Trump administration of voter fraud but is also now caught in the middle of an AI lawyering dispute.

Bhengura’s case is one of a few dozen in which the Trump administration found disparate cases of voter fraud (which is exceedingly rare) and made big, public shows of the arrests it made. Beyond the political implications of the case, the filings by the Department of Justice show that attorneys are now trying to catch each other using AI, and are centering some of their arguments to the judge around the idea that their opposition is wasting the court’s time with AI-generated filings. 

The case is taking place in federal court in the Northern District of Texas, which recently implemented a rule requiring attorneys to disclose generative AI use in filings. In some of the filings, Bhengura’s attorneys wrote “portions of this brief were prepared with the assistance of a generative artificial intelligence tool.” Government attorneys ran several of the filings through Pangram, the AI writing detection service, and filed the results as exhibits to one of its arguments. 

The Pangram results for the filings were mixed (as in, they did not show that the briefings were 100 percent AI-drafted), but the government’s attorneys wrote that they did not feel like they should have to respond substantively to briefs that were partially AI-generated.

The United States has “been trying to economize the amount of effort it puts into responding to Defendant’s meritless motions given that Defendant appears to be almost entirely using AI to generate them,” the DOJ attorneys wrote.

“As the Court can see from a cursory review of the results of Bhengura’s motions, most of the non-AI generated text in these filings consists of statements from third parties other than Defense counsel, including statements from evidence or documents in the record or quotes from caselaw. In other words, virtually nothing of substance in these filings seems to have been drafted by a human on the Defense team,” they added.

The Department of Justice Is Using AI Detector Pangram Against Defense Attorneys
The Department of Justice Is Using AI Detector Pangram Against Defense Attorneys

The judge in the case, Mark Pittman, chastised the defense attorneys for their use of AI, and wrote, “This Court is disturbed by counsel’s repeated filings which subtly bend the law by proffering superficially persuasive but fundamentally meritless arguments so clearly generated by artificial intelligence. Defendant is not a pro se litigant; he has three counsel of record with decades of practice between them. It is distressing to see how quickly the advent of artificial intelligence has undermined counsels’ ability to properly advocate for their client.”

Nicole Knox and Mario Herrera, two of Bhengura’s attorneys, told 404 Media that the story isn’t so simple, and say they felt they had to use AI because of a health emergency and in order to meet the court’s tight filing deadlines ahead of the election. Herrera said Knox “experienced a medical emergency while we were at the U.S. Attorney's Office preparing the case with the prosecutors […] thus, I prepared a federal jury trial in four days with the lead attorney in the hospital.”

“I represented my client to the best of my abilities within this limited timeframe. I utilized all available legal tools and did not violate any rules or laws in doing so,” he said. 

“The government's ‘evidence’ consisted of output from Pangram, an AI-detection software. An AI-detection software identifies patterns in writing styles based upon a document’s content. It cannot determine who wrote a document, how it was written, or if the law applied within a document is correct,” Herrera added. “The U.S. Attorney's Office did not identify any false citations. ‘Defense by ChatGPT’ is a label the government placed in a court filing regarding the defense of a 70-year-old permanent resident facing prison and deportation. It is not a factual statement. And the attorneys who wrote it were present when Ms. Knox collapsed. They knew precisely why I was standing alone with a new co-counsel in that courtroom four days later. There was nothing requiring them to state what they stated.” 

Pangram CEO Max Spero told 404 Media that anecdotally, he has heard that law firms have begun to use his company’s software, but that most use cases he has seen have been from firms using the tool internally to check whether their junior attorneys and paralegals are using AI to draft legal briefs. 

Herrera said that the fact that Bhengura was found not guilty on one of the three counts he faced is evidence that “Mr. Bhengura received the representation that he deserved.”

“Lawyers have been using templates, forms, and drafting software for decades. This is merely a newer version of those very tools. The arguments that the judge attacked were written by me. Some portions of the filings were written with the aid of AI but then reviewed and edited by me. All final work product was mine and I stand behind the argument and logic of each and every document,” he added. “It was the use of AI during that week that allowed me to work on many tasks at once and produce so much work in four days.” 

Knox added, “AI could have never come up with our argument,” and said that the new AI disclosure rule has made it such that “if you obtain one sentence or phrase through the use of A.I., then you must disclose it. We have nothing to hide.”

“Mr. Bhengura is 70 years old, a lawful permanent resident of this country, speaks Punjabi, and his English is limited. Our defense on the one count of which the jury acquitted him was that he never knowingly claimed to be a U.S. citizen,” Herrera said. “He has been in custody since the verdict, and in addition to whatever sentence he receives for the offenses of which he has been found guilty, he faces deportation from this country. He is entitled to more compassion and humanity from everyone involved in this case than he has received so far.”

The Department of Justice did not respond to a request for comment.


The Guardian

Latest news, sport, business, comment, analysis and reviews from the Guardian, the world's leading liberal voice

Football Daily | Jürgen Klopp hard-launches his Germany rebuilding project in style

Sign up now! Sign up now! Sign up now? Sign up now!

Barely six weeks ago, Jürgen Klopp’s big home debut in the Germany dugout ended in a deeply frustrating 1-0 Nations League defeat to Greece – but the manager tasked with returning Die Mannschaft to relevance claimed not to care. “I’m completely unbothered,” Klopp trilled unconvincingly. “I’ve lost far more matches than I would have liked, but as long as you draw the right conclusions, a loss is ultimately a piece of information – no different from a win.” It was a quote straight out of the Pierre Sage playbook for unfussed continental coaches – and probably worried a few German FA suits, given Klopp had already threatened to quit at his own unveiling over potential media intrusion and criticism. “If you say tomorrow, ‘he’s [sh!t]’, tell me to my face and I’m out,” Klopp roared to trembling hacks in July. That imagined confrontation now looks unlikely to take place, because his Germany side are suddenly very good indeed.

Continue reading...

Should JD Vance run for president? I say go for it, habibi! | Arwa Mahdawi

Now the vice-president’s luck is turning, he seems reluctant to commit himself to the next presidential race – and I, for one, hate to see it

How do you think history will remember JD Vance? As the first vice-president to spark a vigorous debate about their eyeliner routine? As one of the last public figures to see Pope Francis alive? As the only politician in US history to have been the subject of a rumour about sexual relations with a couch (even though it was unfounded)?

I have no idea. But it seems increasingly unlikely he will be remembered as the 48th president of the US. After Maga’s midterm thrashing, Vance’s political future doesn’t look as bright as it used to. So much so that there has been a flurry of recent headlines debating whether or not Vance, once considered Donald Trump’s heir apparent, may slink away from a presidential run altogether.

Continue reading...

ajpscs posted a photo:

X
© ajpscs

Kokomo Club

Thomas Hawk posted a photo:

Kokomo Club

Miller Paint

Thomas Hawk posted a photo:

Miller Paint

Jennifer Says

Thomas Hawk posted a photo:

Jennifer Says

Let's Get Lost

Thomas Hawk posted a photo:

Let's Get Lost

Over Drive

Thomas Hawk posted a photo:

Over Drive

Painting roses

DirtyGlassEye has added a photo to the pool:

Painting roses

When I leaked the news I mostly unwillingly decided to return to TDR, this time to do both parks, a family member reached out and told me about the Queen of Hearts Banquet Hall, a sitdown exclusive to Tokyo Disneyland that was the closest I was gonna get to western territory food-wise. And he was right, the concept of a hamburger steak is a bit odd from an American perspective (cause we're used to doing the whole thing) but it still gets the job done nicely.
Now I'm no stranger, or opposed to, shooting theme park restaurants and shops (having done that at USJ and Epic Universe in the past) so the exclusivity already had my brain alight with ideas. Had a bad premonition out the gate since the exterior, a roof made to look like the hedge maze from the movie, was scaffolded, ruining any hope of the shot. But once I entered the mood changed, some areas were empty enough to try to take photos and vibrant enough, courtesy of some of of the club cards for bringing that out so I didn't have to. Before reaching the counter service area in the line you get one last view on a switchback of the entry hallway and there was only 1 person out near the window, that's good enough for me to try. Those red cards posing perfectly, and getting lower to the ground to get those pinkish buds in the back in the frame at the expense of having that black and uninteresting ceiling. But that would soon be fixed.
In editing, I did something I haven't done in a LONG time, I pulled out an old trick from one of my first USJ posts, cloning the ceiling lights across a sizeable portion of the photo to create a starfield, and it worked. I erased two other people walking around the corner and their reflection on the glossy floor. Lowering the shadows to manually independent levels on each card soldier and making sure the cards and the floor are what draw eyes into the photo. Just MAYBE I could pass this as a vanishing point (though that group may just reject me yet again).
I hate Disney

Shrine in the Forest

Pstrey has added a photo to the pool:

Shrine in the Forest

Geen troost voor Nederland

Achter gesloten deuren, daar speelt zich het interessantste deel van onze levens af. Vooral na nederlagen blijven deze deuren zo lang mogelijk potdicht. Daarom zagen we die arme Eva Wiessing van de NOS dagenlang blauwbekken bij de poorten van een Hilversums landgoed, waar vier Nederlandse politici door het stof moesten voor de nederlaag die ze een vrouwelijke collega hadden toegebracht.

Vrij nemen voor GTA VI: ‘Het is gewoon leuk om de slechterik te spelen’

Het is een van de meest gehypte game-releases allertijden: deze donderdag komt Grand Theft Auto VI uit, de nieuwste editie van de razend populaire misdaadspellen van Rockstar Games. NRC sprak drie gamers die nauwelijks meer kunnen wachten.

Turkse regering wijst bewindvoerder aan bij tv-zender Sözcü TV, volgende oppositiekanaal onder controle van regering

Sözcü TV was een van de laatst overgebleven oppositiekanalen in Turkije, waar de media de afgelopen jaren klap na klap te verwerken hebben gekregen.

Wel.nl

Minder lezen, Meer weten.

Twee op de drie zorgpolissen kosten in 2027 meer dan €2.000, maar bij de goedkoopste betaal je €649 per jaar minder dan bij de duurste

Doe je niets aan je zorgverzekering, dan loopt je polis gewoon door in 2027. De kans is groot dat je dan voor het eerst meer dan €2.000 per jaar aan basispremie betaalt. Volgens een analyse van vergelijkingssite Overstappen.nl zitten 42 van de 62 basispolissen volgend jaar boven die grens.

Toch wordt niet elke polis even duur. Tussen de goedkoopste en de duurste basisverzekering zit €649 per jaar.

Van 11 naar 42 polissen boven de €2.000

Dit jaar kostten nog 11 van de 61 polissen meer dan €2.000 per jaar. In één jaar is dat aantal dus bijna verviervoudigd. Overstappen.nl rekende met het verplichte eigen risico van €400, zonder vrijwillig eigen risico en zonder collectiviteitskorting. Geen enkele polis wordt goedkoper: alle 61 polissen die in beide jaren bestaan, gaan omhoog.

De gemiddelde premie komt uit op €173,13 per maand, €14,83 meer dan in 2026. Op jaarbasis is dat €2.077,56. Het kabinet ging in de Miljoenennota nog uit van een gemiddelde jaarpremie van €2.029.

Ook de naturapolis gaat over de grens

De grootste verschuiving zit bij de naturapolissen, meestal de goedkopere variant. In 2026 kostte geen enkele naturapolis meer dan €2.000 per jaar. Volgend jaar geldt dat voor 22 van de 41. Bij de combinatiepolissen, waarbij je vrijer bent in je keuze van zorgverlener, steeg het aantal boven de grens van 11 naar 20 van de 21. De enige combinatiepolis die eronder blijft, is volgens de cijfers VinkVink.

Aan welke kant van de €2.000 zit jij?

De grens ligt bij ongeveer €166,67 per maand. Dit zijn de maandpremies voor 2027 van de grote polissen bij verplicht eigen risico, met daarachter het jaarbedrag:

  • VinkVink: €148,40 per maand, €1.780,80 per jaar
  • Zilveren Kruis Basis Start: €159,45, €1.913,40 per jaar
  • Menzis Basis Voordelig: €160,75, €1.929 per jaar
  • Zilveren Kruis Basis Zeker: €164,95, €1.979,40 per jaar
  • Menzis Basis: €165,75, €1.989 per jaar
  • VGZ Basis Keuze: €167,40, €2.008,80 per jaar
  • VGZ Ruime Keuze: €170,75, €2.049 per jaar
  • CZ Zorg-op-maatpolis: €177,25, €2.127 per jaar
  • Zilveren Kruis Basis Exclusief: €186,95, €2.243,40 per jaar
  • Menzis Basis Vrij: €188,25, €2.259 per jaar
  • CZ Zorgvariatiepolis: €202,50, €2.430 per jaar

Opvallend: de populairste polissen van Zilveren Kruis en Menzis blijven er net onder, die van VGZ en CZ gaan er net overheen. Volgens Zorgwijzer lagen de populairste polissen van de vier grote verzekeraars vorig jaar nog geen €6 per maand uit elkaar. Dat verschil is nu meer dan verdubbeld.

Bij de uitersten scheelt het €54 per maand

De goedkoopste polis blijft VinkVink, het online label van Menzis, met €1.780,80 per jaar. De duurste is de Zorgvariatiepolis van CZ met €2.430. Dat is de eerste basisverzekering die meer dan €200 per maand kost. Het gat tussen die twee is €649 per jaar, of €54 per maand. Een jaar eerder was dat volgens Zorgwijzer nog €511.

Een rekenvoorbeeld: zit je bij de CZ Zorg-op-maatpolis en blijf je zitten, dan betaal je €2.127. Bij Zilveren Kruis Basis Zeker is dat €147,60 minder, bij VinkVink €346,20 minder. Met een partner op dezelfde polis verdubbelen die bedragen.

Dezelfde zorg, andere polisvorm

Wat er in de basisverzekering zit, ligt vast in de Zorgverzekeringswet. De dekking is daarom bij elke verzekeraar gelijk, benadrukt de Stichting Klachten en Geschillen Zorgverzekeringen (SKGZ). Het verschil zit in de premie en in de polisvorm: hoeveel je vergoed krijgt als je naar een zorgverlener gaat waarmee je verzekeraar geen contract heeft.

Daar zit ook de kanttekening. Elke verzekeraar heeft andere contracten met ziekenhuizen en zorgverleners, waarschuwt Zorgwijzer, en dat merk je pas als je zorg nodig hebt. Goedkoper is dus niet automatisch beter. Behandel je al bij een vast ziekenhuis of een vaste therapeut, check dan eerst of die gecontracteerd is bij de polis waar je naar kijkt.

Bovenop de premie komt het eigen risico

Heb je zorg nodig, dan betaal je naast die premie ook het verplichte eigen risico van €400. Eerder schreef WEL al over de aanvullende pakketten in "Je basispremie stijgt tot €25 per maand, maar je aanvullende verzekering blijft bij DSW, Menzis en Interpolis vrijwel even duur" en over het vrijwillig eigen risico in "Koos je voor €900 eigen risico om te besparen? Juist dan stijgt je laagste premie in 2027 bijna drie keer zo hard".

Overstappen kan nog tot en met 31 december. Pak je polisblad van 2027 erbij, vermenigvuldig de maandpremie met twaalf en je ziet meteen aan welke kant van de €2.000 je zit.

Bronnen: Overstappen.nl, ANP Persportaal, Overstappen.nl (premiekloof), Zorgwijzer, Zorgwijzer (Zilveren Kruis), Radar, Overstappen.nl (Menzis en VinkVink), SKGZ


Leveranciers Bruna-eigenaar steunen adempauze, maar zijn kritisch

BREDA (ANP) - Audax, het moederbedrijf van boekwinkelketen Bruna, krijgt mogelijk meer tijd om afspraken te maken met schuldeisers. Veel schuldeisers en leveranciers van Audax hebben geen bezwaar tegen een afkoelingsperiode, bleek dinsdag tijdens een zitting bij de rechtbank waar de financiële problemen bij het bedrijf werden besproken. Wel willen zij duidelijke afspraken en voorwaarden, bijvoorbeeld over betalingen.

Bij de zitting waren ruim tien schuldeisers en leveranciers aanwezig, waaronder distributiebedrijf CB, PostNL, Staatsloterij en verschillende uitgevers. Op tafel lag onder meer de vraag of de afkoelingsperiode verlengd moet worden, wat Audax de kans zou geven zijn voortbestaan veilig te stellen. De rechter in Breda had Audax begin deze maand al een voorlopige adempauze gegund.

Verschillende partijen stelden dat zij erbij zijn gebaat als Audax, waar bijvoorbeeld ook de ReadShop en distributiebedrijf Betapress onder vallen, blijft voortbestaan. "We gaan niet onze branche om zeep helpen", aldus een van de uitgevers.

Kortere afkoelingsperiode

Sommige belanghebbenden pleitten voor een kortere afkoelingsperiode. Ook werd gevraagd om een observator, die erop toeziet dat een eventueel akkoord ook in het belang van de schuldeisers is. Daarnaast wierpen sommigen op dat de informatievoorziening tekortschiet aan de kant van Audax en benadrukten zij niet benadeeld te willen worden.

"De verzochte afkoelingsperiode stelt Audax in staat om de ingestelde weg naar herstel te vervolgen", zei de advocaat van het winkel- en uitgeefbedrijf. Audax ziet verschillende mogelijkheden voor een akkoord en noemt het "niet uitgesloten" dat schuldeisers volledig of bijna helemaal worden terugbetaald. Het concern heeft ook al een regeling in het leven geroepen waarbij uitgevers een voorschot krijgen op de betalingen voor nieuwe leveringen.

Kort geding

Audax stelt ook dat als één vennootschap omvalt, dat leidt tot problemen binnen het hele bedrijf. "Het maakt dat de overleving van alle onderdelen van de groep beter is voor iedere schuldeiser bij iedere vennootschap", benadrukt de advocaat.

Ook bestuurlijk gezien is het onrustig bij Audax. Voor de oorzaak van de problemen wijst Audax onder meer naar de nieuwe eigenaren, verenigd in Lector Capital. Dat consortium zou 8,6 miljoen euro aan financiering hebben toegezegd, maar dit nooit hebben overgemaakt. Audax heeft een kort geding aangespannen om dit geld alsnog te krijgen. De datum daarvan is nog niet bekend.


VK: Voorpagina

Volkskrant.nl biedt het laatste nieuws, opinie en achtergronden

Een dubbele pet voor Sybrand Buma? Experts zien geen belemmering maar wel een risico

Jetten moet nu de VVD zien te bedienen zonder zijn eigen partij van zich te vervreemden

The Register

Biting the hand that feeds IT — Enterprise Technology News and Analysis

Nvidia places chip exports under boardroom supervision after Huang's exit

Nvidia's board has created a national security and export control committee amid intense scrutiny over co-founder and former CEO Jensen Huang's departure and allegations that Singapore-based customer Megaspeed diverted GPUs to China. The National Security and Export Control Oversight Committee, announced on Tuesday, will monitor Nvidia's national security policies, export compliance, and global trade risks. It will meet at least quarterly. The committee will be chaired by director Suzanne Nora Johnson and include directors Stephen C. Neal and John O. Dabiri as members. Nvidia's existing National Security and Global Trade Compliance teams will report on day-to-day operations directly to this new committee, as well as to interim CEO Colette Kress. The panel will oversee efforts to strengthen Nvidia's national security and trade compliance teams and retain independent legal, national security, and trade experts. The announcement follows the resignation of Huang last week after he admitted to an affair with Chinese businesswoman Alice Huang, a Megaspeed executive, and was allegedly involved in a second relationship with an Nvidia employee. US authorities reportedly suspected Alice Huang of working for Chinese intelligence, an allegation that has not been proven. Megaspeed has separately faced scrutiny over suspected export control violations. The US Department of Commerce and Department of Justice confirmed on Tuesday in a joint statement that they were investigating Megaspeed back in 2024. The agencies said they would pursue any criminal conduct uncovered by the investigation. However, Singapore's Ministry of Home Affairs stated that US authorities had provided only "limited assistance" when they were investigating the activities of Alice Huang and Megaspeed, as The Register reported. The New York Times also reported that US investigations into Megaspeed were halted last year after an Nvidia executive contacted Commerce Department officials. The Commerce Department's Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS) has issued new regulations tightening up restrictions on AI technology exports and cloud operators offering remote access to it. The US also expanded its Pax Silica initiative, getting allied nations to sign an agreement that "guarding AI supply chains" is a shared responsibility. Nvidia says it recognizes that advanced silicon and AI technologies present challenges for national security, and it has a responsibility to address them. "We are committed to working constructively with government and industry partners to help establish and advance a robust framework that uses every tool at our disposal to safeguard national security while supporting continued technological innovation," said Harvey Jones, chair of Nvidia's board of directors. ®